DESCRIPTION |
NOTE:
This text is a summary of the COSIMAPAPER.ASC located in the DOCUMENT
subdirectory. The reader is suggested to use the more readable pdf
version of this document, COSIMAPAPER.PDF.
This document has an additional chapter 3, which simply lists the
properties of each substrate.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Functional Description
- 3. Collection Substrates
- 4. In-Flight Operation
- 5. The Ground Laboratory Program
- 6. Anticipated Results
- 7. References
COSIMA - High Resolution Time-of-Flight Secondary Ion Mass
Spectrometer for the Analysis of Cometary Dust Particles onboard
ROSETTA
1 Introduction
The ESA mission Rosetta, launched on March 2nd, 2004, carries an
instrument suite to the comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko. The COmetary
Secondary Ion Mass Anaylzer - COSIMA - is one of three cometary dust
analyzing instruments onboard Rosetta. COSIMA is based on the
analytic measurement method of secondary ion mass spectrometry
(SIMS). The experiment's goal is in-situ analysis of the elemental
composition (and isotopic composition of key elements) of cometary
grains. The chemical characterization will include the main organic
components, present homologous and functional groups, as well as the
mineralogical and petrographical classification of the inorganic
phases. All this analysis is closely related to the chemistry and
history of the early solar system. COSIMA covers a mass range from 1
to 3500 amu with a mass resolution m/dm @ 50 % of 2000 at mass 100
amu. Cometary dust is collected on special, metal covered targets,
which are handled by a target manipulation unit. Once exposed to the
cometary dust environment, the collected dust grains are located on
the target by a microscopic camera. A pulsed primary indium ion beam
(among other entities) releases secondary ions from the dust grains.
These ions, either positive or negative, are selected and accelerated
by electrical fields and travel a well-defined distance through a
drift tube and an ion reflector. A microsphere plate with dedicated
amplifier is used to detect the ions. The arrival times of the ions
are digitized, and the mass spectra of the secondary ions are
calculated from these time-of-flight spectra. Through the instrument
commissioning, COSIMA took the very first SIMS spectra of the targets
in space. COSIMA will be the first instrument applying the SIMS
technique in-situ to cometary grain analysis as Rosetta approaches
the comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, after a long journey of 10
years, in 2014.
The in situ chemical analysis of solids in space is among the tasks
that are technically most difficult. There are two main reasons for
that: With a few exceptions, solids in space are not abundant, and,
secondly, it is not easy to remove small samples from the solid into
the vacuum for the analysis in a mass spectrometer.
For COSIMA, the objects of interest are cometary dust particles,
which are abundant, indeed, in the neighborhood of the comet nucleus.
It remains, however, to collect and bring the particles to the
entrance of the spectrometer.
Most mass spectrometers need the parts of the sample to be analyzed,
to carry an electric charge. The process of removing an ion from the
specimen is then the critical feature of the method to be chosen.
The only mass spectrometric data on cometary dust particles available
to date come from the dust impact mass spectrometers PIA, PUMA, and
CIDA on the GIOTTO, VEGA, and Stardust spacecrafts, respectively.
(Far more and more detailed mass spectra of IDPs of supposed cometary
origin are available from laboratory measurements, and soon there
will be results from the cometary dust particles retrieved from
Stardust.) While other, remote, or indirect methods allow
measurements of collective properties of the cometary dust, the mass
spectrometers allowed the analysis of individual particles (cf.
Kissel et al. 1986a, b). Since then, we know unambiguously that each
particle is an intimate mixture of a mineral component and simple as
well as complex organic molecules. Since the impact velocity was
large (>60 km/s), mostly atomic ions were formed and analyzed in the
Halley case. In a first attempt, however, Kissel and Krueger (1987)
found evidence for the chemical nature of the organic cometary
material. It is clear that not only a few well known molecules
constitute the cometary organics, but rather several chemical
classes, with each being represented by a large number of individual
substances. Indeed, it seems possible that all stable molecules
compatible with the chemical environment are formed.
COSIMA therefore needed to be based on a method, which is readily
available in laboratory, and which allows for tracing the ion
directly to the molecular and structural form in which it was present
in the solid. Since the size distribution of the dust particles is
known (cf. Mazets et al. 1987, McDonnell et al. 1989), a reasonable
ionizing beam focus should be achieved under the limitations of space
instrumentation. Even though the method would be destructive, its
sensitivity should be high enough to allow several analyses at
different depths for one individual ~20 um particle.
To satisfy all these requirements, we choose the method of Secondary
Ion Mass Spectrometry (SIMS). A fast primary ion, in this case 115In+
at 8 keV, impacts the sample and releases by desorption atoms and
molecules of the sample, of which typically 0.1 to 10 % are ionized,
the so-called secondary ions. For sensitivity reasons, the analysis
of a rather large mass range should be achieved simultaneously, which
in turn leads to the type of a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. The
mass resolution must be high enough to resolve isobaric ions, at
least atomic from molecular ions. The mass range should at least
cover 3500 amu. In total, the COSIMA instrument has the following
main functional hardware elements:
* dust collector and target manipulator,
* COSISCOPE, a microscope for target inspection
* primary ion source, and
* mass spectrometer including the ion extraction optics and the
ion detector.
Of course, for autonomous operation, the entire instrument is under
microprocessor based software control.
The overall parameters and resources describing COSIMA are:
* Atomic mass range 1 . . . 3500 amu
* Rel. atomic mass resolution m/dm (at m = 100 amu) > 2000 at 50%
peak width
* Indium ion pulse duration about 3 ns
* Indium ion energy 8 keV
* Ion beam width about 50 um FWHM
* Telemetry rate about 500 bit/sec
* Mass 19.8 kg
* Power consumption from 28 V DC 20.4 W
2 Functional Description
COSIMA is a time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometer. Like all
such instruments, primary ions generate secondary ions from a target,
which they hit. Those secondary ions are then accelerated to the
same, constant kinetic energy, and their flight time to the ion
detector is measured. This flight time follows the equation:
(1) time-of-flight = a * (mass/abs(q))0.5 + b;
with a - is an instrumental constant depending on the length of the
flight path and the electrical voltages applied, for COSIMA it is
about 3.1 us/(mass)0.5
b - is a constant for the offset of the time measurement
mass - is the ion mass in amu
q - is the ion charge state, in most cases = -1 or +1
COSIMA works pretty much like a laboratory instrument, with a
somewhat reduced performance due to the limitations for a space
instrument, but remotely operated in a 'distant lab'. The limitations
come first of all from the mass and power available, but more
pronounced from the limited capacity of data transfer to and from the
instrument, combined with a reaction time (round trip time delay) of
32 minutes during the main operation time.
Consequently the individual steps for the analysis of a dust particle
are:
1) exposure of a collection substrate for a predetermined time
2) optical search of the substrate for dust particles by the camera
system COSISCOPE
3a) moving a dust particle in front of the spectrometer
3b) either first clean the particle and surrounding by sputtering or
3c) start the particle characterization
6) perform onboard chemistry
7) do another detailed analysis in both, the positive and the
negative, ion modes
8) move to the next particle
COSIMA has dedicated surfaces for the collection of cometary dust
particles. These may impact with their release speed of the order of
100 m/s. Since SIMS is a very sensitive method, the collection
surfaces need to be a material, which does not interfere with
the type of materials expected in the dust. This excluded any kind
of organic material. A study performed identified metal blacks as
suitable materials from the structural, and silver, palladium, gold,
or platinum from the material properties point of view. The choice has
turned out to be very sensible, as these blacks are also efficient
pumps for contaminants unavoidable for a space instrument. Since the
cometary particles can have a wide range of speeds depending on their
size and on the gas activity of the nucleus, each unit of targets has
three 1*1 cm2 collection areas (substrates) and a separate 0.3*3 cm2
strip as an unexposed reference area. Always an entire target
assembly is exposed at a time.
Manipulation of the target units is achieved with the Target
Manipulator Unit (TMU), which was designed and added at a late state.
It is a semiautonomous system, which provides access to the
positions 'COLLECT', 'STORE', 'COSISCOPE', 'CLEAN', 'ANALYZE', and
'CHEMISTRY' upon simple (internal) commands.
The first inspection of the sample is done by COSISCOPE, a COSIMA
internal camera. One of the 3 collection substrates is checked at a
time. Light beams from two sets of LEDs left and right of the sample
illuminate it. The images are checked for features like, e.g.,
shadows and interpreted as sites, the coordinates of which are
transferred to the main instrument.
The next step is the decision if the target, or a part of it, needs
cleaning by ion-sputtering. If so, it is moved in front of a DC ion
beam at the 'CLEAN' position, else, it will be presented to the mass
spectrometer. The primary ion source (PIBS) has a separate beam for
cleaning, providing 10-100 uA on a 100 um diameter spot equivalent to
removing some 100 monolayers per second. The next step is to analyze
a site, i.e., to take a mass spectrum. The target is put in front of
the extraction lens of the spectrometer, with the selected site
within 100 um of the lens' center. Operational values are taken from
the initial adjustment of the primary ion source. Trains of ion
packages of 3 ns width at a rate of 1 kHz release secondary ions into
the spectrometer. Its second order focusing design provides an
inherent mass resolution of m/dm @ 50 % peak height above 3000 (i.e.,
with 0-time spread of the primary beam). A typical primary ion
package has 500 ions and releases 1 to 10 non-hydrogen secondary
ions, depending on the material irradiated.
All secondary ions of the appropriate polarity are picked up by the
electric field in front of the ion extraction lens. This field of
about 1 kV/mm minimizes initial time-of-flight differences due to the
acceleration process, which cannot be compensated later. The lens
field also guides the ions into the time-of-flight section of the
instrument reducing their drift energy to nominally 1 keV and focuses
their arrival location on the detector into a 15 mm diameter area. As
the ions travel down the drift tube, they pass the secondary
deflection plates, which are needed to reposition the secondary ion
package, should the analysis site be off center. It is also used to
compensate the small changes in ion trajectories between the positive
and negative secondary ions modes. At the end of the drift tube the
ions enter the ion reflector, the device, which improves the
intrinsic mass resolution of the spectrometer part by more than a
factor of 100. State-of-the-art would be a gridless reflector ( which
we have studied) but which is very sensitive to the position
of the ion entry and thereby on the perfect function of the
secondary deflection plates. The actual design we have chosen
uses several grids separating the drift section, the retarding
section, and the reflecting section. As the ions enter under a small
angle of 1deg, they exit at a slightly different location but again
into the same physical drift tube. At the end of this tube the ions
hit the ion detector. The position and the orientation of the
detector were carefully chosen, as both are part of the system, which
determines the mass resolution of COSIMA. Since we expect some of the
organic ions to have high masses (well above 350 amu) the detector
can be biased for a post-acceleration of the secondary ions by almost
9 kV (with the appropriate polarity for the respective ion type). The
active element is a microsphere plate, which for its thickness of 1.4
mm provides a gain value well above 107. In order to decouple the
signal from its high electrical potential (up to 14 kV in the case of
negative secondary ions), the microsphere output is directed to an
anode, which is one side of a capacitor, while the other side is
connected to the input of a pulse amplifier. All arrival times and
shot numbers are stored at 2 ns resolution. The differences between
the modes for positive or negative secondary ions are reflected in
the respective operational voltages. Besides the reversal of
polarity, minor adjustments need to be applied to the voltages for
the deflection plates of both, the primary beam and the secondary ion
path. The safe switch-over from one ion type to the other will take a
couple of minutes to allow the high voltages to decay, before the
grounding of the power supplies is switched. The secondary ion
arrival times are accumulated into the time-bins of a time-of-flight
spectrum.
3. Collection Substrates
The 24 target holders are numbered with hexadecimal numbers from #C1
to #D8. The top substrate is marked with the number #100, the middle
with #200 and the low with #300. The combination of these numbers give
the substrate identification number used in the instrument commanding
and data handling.
The list bellow gives the substrates ID, the surface layer properties
and a possible comment
#1C1 'Palladium, black'
#2C1 'Platinum, deep black'
#3C1 'Platinum, deep black'
#1C2 'Silver, 73 micrometer thickness,
blank with rectangular hole 3.5x3.5mm'
#2C2 'Silver, 69 micrometer thickness,
blank with AgTe spot of about 3 mm size at center'
#3C2 'Gold, 17 micrometer thickness, olivine particles'
#1C3 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
#2C3 'Gold, 15 micrometer thickness'
#3C3 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1C4 'Palladium, black'
#2C4 'Silver, 14 micrometer thickness'
#3C4 'Gold, 12 micrometer thickness'
#1C5 'Platinum, light black,'
#2C5 'Platinum, deep black'
#3C5 'Gold, 13 micrometer thickness'
#1C6 'Platinum, deep black'
#2C6 'Platinum, deep black'
#3C6 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
#1C7 'Silver, blank'
#2C7 'Silver, 21 micrometer thickness'
#3C7 'Gold, 15 micrometer thickness'
#1C8 'Platinum, deep black'
#2C8 'Platinum, deep black'
#3C8 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1C9 'Gold, 5-8 micrometer thickness'
#2C9 'Gold, 5-8 micrometer thickness'
#3C9 'Gold, 11 micrometer thickness'
#1CA 'Gold, 5-8 micrometer thickness'
#2CA 'Gold, 16 micrometer thickness'
#3CA 'Silver, 10 micrometer thickness'
#1CB 'Gold, 17 micrometer thickness'
#2CB 'Gold, 14 micrometer thickness'
#3CB 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1CC 'Silver, 21 micrometer thickness'
#2CC 'Silver, 21 micrometer thickness'
#3CC 'Silver, 24 micrometer thickness'
#1CD 'Gold, 5-8 micrometer thickness'
#2CD 'Gold, 14 micrometer thickness'
#3CD 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1CE 'Gold, 5-8 micrometer thickness, Ag particles'
#2CE 'Gold, 11 micrometer thickness'
#3CE 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1CF 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
#2CF 'Gold, 12 micrometer thickness, Ag particles'
#3CF 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#1D0 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#2D0 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness'
#3D0 'Gold, 20-30 micrometer thickness, Ag particles'
#1D1 'Silver, blank'
#2D1 'Gold, 13 micrometer thickness'
#3D1 'Gold, 13 micrometer thickness'
#1D2 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
#2D2 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
#3D2 'Silver, 30 micrometer thickness'
#1D3 'Silver, 10 micrometer thickness'
#2D3 'Silver, 10 micrometer thickness'
#3D3 'Silver, 32 micrometer thickness'
#1D4 'Platinum, sintered'
#2D4 'Platinum, deep black'
#3D4 'Platinum, deep black'
#1D5 'Platinum, deep black'
#2D5 'Silver, 22 micrometer thickness'
#3D5 'Silver, 21 micrometer thickness'
#1D6 'Platinum, deep black'
#2D6 'Palladium, black'
#3D6 'Platinum, deep black'
#1D7 'Silver, blank'
#2D7 'Platinum, sintered'
#3D7 'Platinum, sintered'
#1D8 'Silver, blank, square hole 3.5x3.5mm at center'
#2D8 'Silver, blank'
#3D8 'Gold, 8 micrometer thickness'
4 In-Flight Operation
Rosetta commissioning was carried out in 2004, the COSIMA instrument
was operated in-flight after nearly a decade of development and tests
on the ground. Positive and negative SIMS ion mass spectra were taken
of one of the Ag metal targets, the resulting spectra are shown in
Fig. 18a and Fig. 18b, respectively. The inorganic and organic ions
and molecules show up in separable and well resolved mass peaks, such
as Si and C2H4 or Fe and C4H8. Small amounts of organic molecules
being known to be present in cometary dust such as CN are adsorbed on
the blank metal target and reveal themselves in the SIMS mass
spectra. Since COSIMA carries also a heating station for the target,
the level of volatile contamination can be further decreased before
exposure of the target to the cometary dust. Comparison with mass
spectra taken of the same target in 2002 before launch already shows
a slight decrease of volatiles such as hydrocarbons absorbed on the
target surface after residing only about 6 months in space. This
contamination by organic molecules was, in part, released from the
insulation material of the electrical harness and from boxes used for
ground transportation. Note that the Ag peaks are caused by ions
released from the target and the In peak is due to primary ions from
the ion source. For high secondary ion rates, the mass spectra show
saturation effects due to dead-times inherent in the ion detector
counting electronics, best visible adjacent to each of the intense Ag
isotope peaks.
5 The Ground Laboratory Program
During the cruise phase to the comet as well as while the probe is
actually analyzing cometary dust, an active laboratory program will
be maintained. While the SIMS method is routinely applied for
relevant geological and planetological studies, the TOF-SIMS
technique will benefit from this terrestrial work with the COSIMA RM
reference model. Additionally, growing experimental and
methodological expertise comes from the day-to-day work with relevant
samples at the TOF-SIMS laboratory instrument currently in use at the
University of Munster. The complex mixture of organic and inorganic
material, expected to make up the comet, will result in equally
complex mass spectra. They have to be disentangled to provide
information on the chemical, isotopic, and molecular composition of
the particles that reflect the origin, history, and present state of
cometary matter. The particle-to-particle variation will testify to
its diversity, i.e., to the extent of the pristine nature of these
materials, and to its stellar sources. Interpreting the mass spectra
requires calibration. Calibration here is not meant to mimic the
experiment in a one-to-one scale in the laboratory, but rather to
understand the processes, which control ion formation with complex
samples, as well as the instrumental parameters of mass separation
and ion detection. To that end, state-of-the-art laboratory TOF-SIMS
analyses with utmost lateral and mass resolution of various materials
available on Earth will be performed, which include, but are not
limited to:
Interplanetary dust particles (IDPs): Some of these small and
difficult-to-analyze particles actually may stem from comets. It is
an active research topic to sort these out and distinguish them from
asteroidal IDPs. IDPs of a certain class are mixtures of inorganic
and organic matter and as such represent the best analog material for
the COSIMA case.
Carbonaceous chondrites: They are mechanical mixtures of fine-grained
low-temperature matrix and carbon-rich phases (kerogen) with high-
temperature clasts, single minerals, and chondrules. Their overall
chemical composition is solar as far as the condensable elements are
concerned. They most closely represent and witness the Early Solar
System materials and processes. They are regarded as the base line
material in planetology.
Certain IDPs and chondrites contain particles with non-standard
isotopic composition of a number of elements that point towards their
nucleosynthetic stellar sources. These particles (stardust or
presolar particles) will serve to learn how to obtain the relevant
information from cometary matter.
The extraterrestrial materials mentioned above are not as pristine as
we expect cometary dust to be. IDPs are altered to an unknown extent
during passage through the atmosphere, deceleration processes and
residence in the stratosphere; carbonaceous chondrites were subject
to metamorphism and aqueous alteration on their parent bodies.
Consequently, for the analysis of organic (and icy) components
anticipated in cometary particles artificial analogs are needed. They
are siliceous vaporization deposits contaminated with organic
substances. Certainly not all possible organic substances can be
analyzed, but rather we will perform TOF-SIMS measurements of
relevant substance classes.
As mentioned above, these analyses are performed with the highest
possible mass and (where appropriate) lateral resolution. In
addition, the temporal evolution of the mass spectra is evaluated by
using the data from all primary ion pulses. This will give hints to a
possible layering within the material and / or validate influences,
which the TOF-SIMS method may cause in the material (by, e.g.,
'radiation damage'). New statistical and chemometric methods and
procedures, now under test, will be further developed and applied.
The laboratory program will benefit from and be adjusted to new
insights, which will come from the analysis of the samples returned
by Stardust.
6 Anticipated Results
6.1 The Mineral Phase
The anticipated results of the investigation of the mineral phase of
the cometary dust are manifold:
1. First, we shall establish the mean composition of the main
elements, and then check whether this varies from grain to grain,
either within the statistical variance or beyond that. In the
latter case we'll be able to identify various classes of minerals.
2. Second, the distribution of molecular ions should be sensitive to
the order structure of the minerals, may they be in an amorphous or
in one of several crystalline states. This would give an important
clue to the thermal and radiation history of the dust.
3. Third, once an elemental and molecular distribution of the main
isotopic contribution is established, the contribution of the minor
isotopes can be measured from grain to grain, needed for the
question whether various stellar sources have played a role to form
the dust.
4. Fourth (last but not least), a cross-correlation of the types of
organics sitting upon the same grain will give insight into aspects
of the real grain forming process as well as to possible catalytic
interferences between each phase. This is important for the 'Origin
of Life' topic and its relation to nano-systems.
6.2 The Organic Phase
The refractory organic phase will most probably be an intimate
mixture of a lot of individual species. But still, the history of
grain formation and the incorporation of them into cometary nuclei is
reflected - at least partially - in the distribution of the organic
species. Substance class analysis will provide clues to whether the
organic phase is mainly produced by condensation of vapors and
subsequent radiation processing with polycondensation and
oligomerization, etc., or, if it is mainly produced by condensation
of larger molecules and aggregation of small refractory particles.
Another important question is, whether the organic material in comets
is suitable to start the onset of life on earth. In this case, the
analysis will show that the precursors of such molecules needed for
life's self-organization by exenthalpic reactions with liquid water
are present.
As water usually shows up in different ways in the mass-spectra,
clues to the source of water in the comet may be found, too: is it
just a condensation of water ice in the grains, or, is it the result
of long-term radiation induced processes, such as polycondensation or
Born-Haber-type processes, or is perhaps a fraction of the water in a
comet produced by thermally induced reactions, when the comet
approaches the sun?
COSIMA results thus address the main questions concerning the origin
of the hydrosphere, and further on, the biosphere on earth.
7 References
Kissel, J. et al., COSIMA - High resolution
time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometer for the analysis
of cometary dust particles onboard Rosetta, Space Sci. Rev.,
128(1-4), 823-867, doi:10.1007/s11214-006-9083-0, 2007.
This document is available in the DOCUMENT directory.
-----------------------
|